Ashirwad Food Industries vs Union of India & Ors.
Date of Order: February 9, 2026
Case Law No: GIB-JHC-2026-31
Subject: Quantum of deposite- in case alemond reduced in first appeal – GSTAT -Section 112(8)
Description:
Case Facts:
- The petitioner challenged Order-in-Appeal dated 30.06.2025 confirming GST demand along with interest and penalty.
- Statutory remedy of appeal before GST Appellate Tribunal was available, but the Tribunal was not fully functional.
- Petitioner had already deposited ₹23.85 lakhs at the first appellate stage against an original demand of about ₹2.38 crores, later reduced to about ₹40 lakhs.
- The dispute centered on whether further pre-deposit was required for filing appeal before the Tribunal.
Court Decision:
- Court held that no further pre-deposit is required for filing appeal before GSTAT considering earlier deposit of ₹23.85 lakhs.
- Petitioner permitted to file appeal within four weeks from the date of order.
- Tribunal directed to decide appeal on merits without considering limitation if filed within the stipulated time.
- If electronic filing is not possible, petitioner allowed to file appeal physically and same must be accepted without additional pre-deposit.
- All issues on merits left open for adjudication by the Tribunal.
- Writ petition disposed of without costs.
Other Case Law
Hoosein Kasam Dada (India) Ltd. v. State of Madhya Pradesh
Whether amendment imposing pre-deposit condition for appeal applies retrospectively and affects vested right of appeal
Facts :The assessee filed a sales tax return in 1947 and assessment proceedings ...
Read MoreLord Vishnu Construction Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
Validity of GST assessment where notices were uploaded under “additional notices and orders” on portal and not effectively communicated
Facts :The petitioner challenged an assessment order dated 31.10.2023 passed und...
Read MoreShafhi Mohammad v. State of Himachal Pradesh
Importance of Electronic Evidence
Facts of the CaseThe matter arose from a Special Leave Petition challenging a ju...
Read More