Suresh Kumar vs Commissioner CGST Delhi North
Case Facts:
The petitioner challenged two GST orders and corresponding DRC-07 forms issued in 2025.
For one order, the issue related to consolidated show cause notice for multiple financial years.
For the second order, the petitioner argued limitation as DRC-07 was uploaded after the order date.
The department contended that the order had already been communicated through email prior to DRC-07 upload.
Court Decision:
Held that consolidated notices for multiple financial years are permissible under Sections 73 and 74 using the expression “period”.
Held that communication of order through email constitutes valid service under Section 169.
Observed that delay in uploading DRC-07 does not render the order time-barred if order is otherwise communicated.
Noted that gap between order and DRC-07 upload can occur, especially in cases involving multiple noticees.
Permitted petitioner to file appeal under Section 107 and raise limitation issue therein.
Directed that if appeal is filed within stipulated time (by 30.09.2025), it shall not be dismissed on limitation and be decided on merits.
Cases Referred by Court:
- Ambika Traders through Proprietor Gaurav Gupta v. Additional Commissioner, Adjudication DGGSTI, CGST Delhi North, 2025:DHC:6181-DB
- Raj International v. Additional Commissioner CGST Delhi West & Ors., W.P.(C) 4096/2025
- Udumalpet Sarvodaya Sangham v. Authority under Shop and Establishment Act (Madras High Court)
Other Case Law
State of Karnataka v. M/s Tallam Apparels
Disallowance of Input Tax Credit on allegation of non-genuine transactions and non-payment of tax by selling dealer under VAT (Sections involved: Section 70(1), Section 39(1), and relevant provisions of the Karnataka Value Added Tax Act, 2003)
Facts :The assessee, a registered dealer dealing in garments, claimed input tax ...
Read MoreJoint Commissioner (Intelligence & Enforcement) & Anr. vs Lakshmi Mobile Accessories
Show Cause Notice – Clubbing of multiple financial years in a single show cause notice under Section 74 of the CGST Act, 2017 – requirement of separate adjudication for each financial year.
Facts:The respondent-assessee challenged a show cause notice dated 29.07.2024 is...
Read MoreRaj Shekhar Pandey v. State Tax Officer
Validity of GST proceedings initiated after cancellation of registration and service of notice through portal
Facts :The petitioner challenged the show cause notice dated 16.11.2024 and orde...
Read More