Sri Padmavathi Marketing v. Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes
Case Facts:
The petitioner challenged a show-cause notice proposing blocking of ITC under Rule 86A and seeking restoration of ₹1.96 crore. The allegation was that the petitioner issued invoices without actual supply of goods, enabling M/s. Million Lights to avail wrongful ITC. The petitioner contended that Rule 86A applies only when ITC is wrongly availed by the assessee itself and not by its customer. The department asserted ongoing investigation and alleged admissions regarding issuance of invoices without supply.
Court Decision:
The Court held that Rule 86A empowers restriction on utilization of ITC only when the credit in the electronic credit ledger of the concerned assessee is fraudulently availed or is ineligible under specified circumstances such as absence of supply, non-existent supplier, non-payment of tax, or lack of valid documents. The Rule is limited to these conditions and cannot be invoked otherwise. In the present case, the allegation was that the petitioner issued invoices without actual supply, leading to wrongful ITC availment by the recipient. Such allegation does not pertain to ITC availed by the petitioner itself. Therefore, invocation of Rule 86A against the petitioner was improper as the statutory conditions were not satisfied.
Other Case Law
Frontline Wind Energy Private Limited v. The Assistant Commissioner (ST)
Tax and a hundred per cent penalty confirmed on the entire annual-report value of a windmill undertaking sold as a going concern, contrary to the department’s own earlier notice accepting that the sale consideration was not taxable. At issue: an assessm
Background. The petitioner had acquired a wind electric generator par...
Read MoreGlobeOp Financial Services (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of State Tax & Ors.
Validity of a GST demand order of ₹70,57,98,208/- confirmed by verbatim copying of the show cause notice, without independent application of mind to the petitioner's detailed replies — whether such an order amounts to non-application of mind and viola
BackgroundThe petitioner is engaged in providing financial back-office services ...
Read MoreThe State of Himachal Pradesh and Others v. Yogendera Mohan Sengupta and
Binding nature of law declared by the Supreme Court under Article 141 of the Constitution of India on all Courts, Tribunals, and authorities functioning under a High Court's superintendence — and the requirement of judicial discipline to prevent
Background:Para 1–2, 3.1–3.14: The Himachal Pradesh Town & Country Plann...
Read More