Metal One Corporation India Pvt. Ltd. vs Union of India & Ors.
The petitioners challenged show cause notices proposing levy of GST on secondment of employees from foreign group entities. The factual background indicated that salaries were paid by the Indian entities, and the seconded employees worked under their control. Subsequent clarifications issued by CBIC were also placed on record.
The Court held that once the issue of taxability of secondment stood clarified by the Board, continuation of proceedings was unwarranted. The impugned show cause notices were quashed, holding that the proposed levy was unsustainable in law.
Case laws referred:
Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, (2022) 61 GSTL 129 (SC)
Other Case Law
Sri Ganapathi Pandi Industries vs Assistant Commissioner (State Tax)
Validity of GST assessment orders passed without proper jurisdiction
The petitioner challenged assessment orders passed under the State GST Act on th...
Read MoreShree Shyam Steel vs Union of India & Ors.
Validity of Notification extending limitation without GST Council recommendation
The petitioner challenged Notification No. 56/2023 issued by CBIC extending the ...
Read MoreExcellent Polycon Private Limited vs State Tax Officer, Bureau of Investigation & Ors.
Penalty for expired e-way bill without intent to evade tax
The petitioner challenged penalty orders imposed for transportation of goods wit...
Read More