GST INDIA Biz
GST India .biz — Case Law Details
Detailed GST Case Law Information

Maruti Enterprise v. Union of India & Ors.

Date of Order: May 1, 2026
Case Law No: GIB-GUJHC-2026-151
Subject: Constitutional validity of Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act – whether denial of ITC to a bona fide purchaser for the supplier’s failure to deposit tax violates Articles 14, 19(1)(g), 265 and 300A, or whether the provision should be read down to cases
Description:

Background

In a large group of petitions, purchasing dealers denied ITC because their suppliers had not deposited the tax collected challenged Section 16(2)(c). They argued that the GST system gives a purchaser no means to verify the supplier’s GSTR-3B or tax payment, invoked the maxim lex non cogit ad impossibilia, and relied on On Quest Merchandising (Delhi HC), which read down Section 9(2)(g) of the DVAT Act, and Sahil Enterprises (Tripura HC), which read down Section 16(2)(c). The Court confined itself to the question of vires and did not examine individual merits.

Final Verdict

The Court held that the GST regime cannot be equated with VAT: it is destination-based, ITC crosses State lines, and under Section 53 the originating State would have to transfer tax it never received if credit were allowed without payment. The purchaser is not left remediless, because the Revenue can recover from the supplier under Sections 73 and 74, and Section 41(2) with Rule 37A allows re-availment once the supplier pays; mere delay or hardship in availing ITC cannot constitute a valid ground for reading down Section 16(2)(c). ITC is a statutory concession, Section 155 places the burden of proving eligibility on the claimant, and the Court respectfully disagreed with the Tripura High Court. It held that Section 16(2)(c) is clear, self-explanatory and unambiguous, and its plain reading does not give rise to any constitutional or legal infirmity, and declined to read it down or declare it ultra vires.

In its final observations, the Court referred to the Axel Kittel principle that ITC may be denied only where the recipient knew or ought to have known of the fraud, and urged the Government to re-evaluate the position of honest purchasers, through legislative amendment or clarification, a real-time technology-driven mechanism to verify suppliers’ tax payments against specific invoices, and prompt recovery from erring suppliers. The petitions were directed to be listed for decision on merits.
 

Other Case Law

A.R. Steels vs. The Deputy Assistant Commissioner STL & Others

Whether a writ petition challenging a GST assessment order is maintainable when filed with inordinate and unexplained delay, on the ground that the petitioner could not access the GST portal due to cancellation of registration.

BACKGROUNDThe petitioner, a trader in iron and iron scrap, had its GST registrat...

Read More
ARUN KUMAR JAIN & ORS. v. ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER, CGST DELHI WEST COMMISSIONERATE & ORS.

Challenge to penalties under Sections 74, 76(2) & 122(1) of CGST Act for alleged fraudulent ITC; issues on pre-deposit under Section 107(6) and penalty on non-taxable persons.

BACKGROUNDCommon adjudicatory proceedings concerned allegations that companies h...

Read More
Shanti Kiran India Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner, Trade & Tax Department

Denial of Input Tax Credit to purchasing dealer due to non-payment of tax by selling dealer under DVAT (Section involved: Section 9(1) and Section 9(2) of the Delhi Value Added Tax Act, 2004)

Facts :The appellant, a registered dealer, purchased goods from registered selli...

Read More