GST INDIA Biz
GST India .biz — Case Law Details
Detailed GST Case Law Information

Kanakia Spaces Reality Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of CGST & Central Excise, Mumbai

Date of Order: March 14, 2024
Case Law No: GIB-CESTAT-2024-24
Subject: Refund of service tax paid on flat booking advances where bookings were cancelled and the amount and tax were returned – Section 142(5) of the CGST Act, 2017.
Description:

Background

The appellant, a developer providing construction of residential complex service, collected booking amounts from prospective apartment buyers and paid service tax on them. Several allottees later cancelled their bookings, and the appellant returned the booking amounts along with the service tax collected. Contending that the Rule 6(3) route for adjusting excess service tax was not available in GST returns, it filed three refund claims (6 March, 27 April and 29 June 2018) under Section 11B of the Central Excise Act, 1944 read with Section 142(5) of the CGST Act, 2017, aggregating ₹24,58,250 (revised from ₹35,14,597). The adjudicating authority rejected the claims and the Commissioner (Appeals), by common order dated 11.03.2020, upheld the rejection, holding that the GST law has no provision for such a refund and that mere cancellation does not mean no service was provided. In appeal, the Tribunal examined whether it had jurisdiction over such refund claims and whether the refund was admissible.

Final Verdict

Following the Larger Bench decision in Bosch Electrical Drive India Private Limited v. Commissioner of Central Tax, Chennai (21.12.2023), the Tribunal held that appeals against refund orders under Section 142 of the CGST Act lie before CESTAT and, relying on Wave One Private Limited v. Commissioner of CGST & Central Excise, Delhi CESTAT, New Delhi and Jai Jai Mateshwaari Steels Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner, CGST, Dehradun, Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), New Delhithat the limitation under Section 11B cannot be invoked against claims under Section 142(5). On merits, it held that service tax presupposes a taxable service; where the buyer cancels and receives back the consideration with tax, the service contract stands terminated, the tax deposited is merely a deposit and its retention would violate Article 265 of the Constitution. “If there is no service then question of paying any tax on it does not arise and the Department can’t keep it with them.” The right to refund of excess service tax had accrued to the appellant and was protected by Section 174, with Section 142(5) providing the refund route; the appeals were allowed with consequential relief as per law.


 

Other Case Law

D.Y. Beathel Enterprises v. State Tax Officer (Data Cell), Tirunelveli

Reversal of ITC under Sections 16(1) & 16(2) of the TNGST Act where the supplier failed to remit tax to the Government.

BackgroundThe petitioners were dealers in raw rubber sheets and had purchased go...

Read More
Khalid Buhari vs Assistant Commissioner of CGST and Central Excise & Another

Attachment of director’s bank account for company’s GST liability under Section 89 of the CGST Act without giving opportunity to discharge burden of proof.

Court Decision:The writ petition challenged the recovery notice dated 25.11.2025...

Read More
Panchhi Traders v. State of Gujarat

Whether confiscation under Section 130 CGST Act can be invoked during transit detention under Section 129 and interpretation of amended provisions

Facts :The petitions arose from detention and seizure of goods in transit under ...

Read More