Sterlite Power Transmission Limited & Others v. Union of India & Others
Background
A batch of writ petitions (including Sterlite Power Transmission, ReNew, Jindal Stainless and Azure Power) challenged show cause notices and demands raised on corporate guarantees issued without consideration to banks for group companies, along with Rule 28(2) of the CGST Rules inserted by Notification No. 52/2023-CT dated 26.10.2023 (deemed value of 1%), its amendment by Notification No. 12/2024 dated 10.07.2024 (“located in India” and “per annum”), and Circular Nos. 204/16/2023-GST and 225/19/2024-GST. The Court framed five issues: (a) whether such a guarantee is a supply of services under Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I, and who is the recipient; (b) whether it is excluded as an actionable claim or security; (c) whether Rule 28(2) is intra vires and constitutional; (d) the time of supply and the position for guarantees before 01.07.2017, up to 25.10.2023 and the retrospective effect of the 2024 amendment; and (e) validity of the Circulars.
Final Verdict
The Court held that a corporate guarantee for a related person is a supply of services even without consideration, the service being assumption of the risk of default, with the related person as recipient; Edelweiss was distinguished as it arose under the service tax definition requiring consideration (Paras 71–72, 121). It is neither an actionable claim nor a security (Para 122). Rule 28(2) is intra vires, but making 1% p.a. a fixed minimum is arbitrary under Article 14, so it is read down as a rebuttable presumption displaced by a lower open market value proved by the supplier on cogent material; the proviso is valid (Paras 87–91, 123–124). A guarantee is a single supply on execution and on each renewal, extension or enhancement, taxed under Section 13(2)(a)/(b) and not as a continuous supply; guarantees before 01.07.2017 are not taxable unless renewed, those from 01.07.2017 to 25.10.2023 are taxable but valued under the then Rules without Rule 28(2), and the 2024 amendment is validly retrospective (Paras 125–126). The Circulars are valid but must be read in conformity with the judgment (Para 127). The notices and demands are set aside to the extent contrary to these findings and the proper officers must determine liability afresh after hearing; questions such as Section 74 limitation are left open, and the petitions are partly allowed (Paras 128–131).
Other Case Law
Krishan Pal Singh v. The Additional Commissioner, Delhi West Commissionerate & Anr.
Writ against a penalty-only order arising from a pre-01.10.2025 SCN – merits relegated to appeal, but 10% penalty pre-deposit under the substituted proviso to Section 107(6) not insisted upon.
BackgroundThe petitioner sought quashing of the Order-in-Original dated 31.01.20...
Read MoreKanakia Spaces Realty Private Limited v. The Union of India
A show cause notice and order-in-original issued under a legacy registration migrated automatically into GST, nearly a decade after the entity had merged out of existence. At issue: whether the defect was jurisdictional despite the department having been
Background. Kanakia Supremo Construction Private Limited merged into ...
Read MoreSrei Equipment Finance Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner, DIV-III, CGST & C-EX, Navi Mumbai & Ors.
Continuation of CGST demand proceedings against a corporate debtor for a period prior to approval of its resolution plan under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. At issue: whether statutory dues not forming part of an approved Resolution Plan stand
Background. The matter pertained to CGST dues for the assessment year 2020-...
Read More